Highlights
- Security: India's lack of a formal National Security Strategy (NSS) returned to debate; comparisons with the US, UK and China's formal documents were made.
- Society: The death of a 26-year-old EY employee attributed to overwork sparked a national debate on toxic workplace culture and WHO data on working-hour-related deaths.
- Environment: Bombay High Court struck down the government's Fact-Check Unit for "fake news," citing disproportionate curbs on free speech.
- Geography: Sri Lanka's new President election (AKD) dominated the South Asia mapping section.
1. India's National Security Strategy: the gap
GS area: Governance (security), International Relations
India remains one of the few major powers without a formal, publicly available National Security Strategy (NSS).
Key facts:
- What an NSS does: A formal NSS integrates defence, economic, intelligence and diplomatic priorities into a publicly stated long-term framework. It signals strategic intent to allies, adversaries and domestic stakeholders.
- Countries with formal NSS: United States (updated regularly), United Kingdom, Russia, China and Pakistan all have published formal NSS documents.
- India's attempts: The Kargil Review Committee (2000) recommended creating an NSS after the Kargil conflict exposed coordination failures. General D.S. Hooda's committee (2018-19) made further recommendations.
- Existing coordination bodies: Defence Planning Committee (DPC), established 2018 under the National Security Adviser. Chief of Defence Staff (CDS), created 2020. National Security Council Secretariat (NSCS).
- Why India lacks one: Lack of political consensus on stating priorities. Fear of accountability if a formal strategy fails. Limited culture of strategic publication in the bureaucracy.
- Strategic cost: Without an NSS, India's military, diplomatic and economic arms work without a unifying document. Coalition partners find it harder to align.
- CDS role: The Chief of Defence Staff is meant to integrate the three services and bring jointness. General Anil Chauhan holds this post after General Bipin Rawat's death in December 2021.
Static linkage: National security, civil-military relations, India's strategic culture.
2. Anna Sebastian Perayil: workplace death debate
GS area: Governance (labour), Ethics, Social justice
The death of Anna Sebastian Perayil, a 26-year-old employee of Ernst and Young (EY) India, attributed by her family to excessive work pressure, triggered a national conversation on toxic workplace culture.
Key facts:
- WHO finding: Working 55 hours or more per week constitutes a serious health hazard. The WHO (2021 report) linked long working hours to 745,000 deaths from stroke and heart disease in 2016.
- Hustle culture: The corporate practice of celebrating overwork. A major company's CEO had reportedly advised employees to "work 18 hours a day for 4-5 years." This statement drew significant backlash.
- Labour law provisions: The Occupational Safety, Health and Working Conditions Code (2020), one of India's four labour codes, specifies maximum working hours. The Code is in the legislative stage and its rules are partially notified.
- GS Paper 4 angle: Ethical dimensions include employer duty of care, the culture of retaliation against those who raise concerns, and the power imbalance between employees and corporations.
- OECD comparison: OECD countries average around 1,700 hours worked annually. India's informal sector frequently sees much longer hours.
Static linkage: Labour welfare, occupational safety, Ethics (GS Paper 4).
3. Fact-Check Unit struck down by Bombay High Court
GS area: Polity (fundamental rights), Governance
The Bombay High Court struck down the IT (Amendment) Rules 2023 provision that allowed the Central government to establish a Fact-Check Unit (FCU) to flag "fake, false, or misleading" information about government business.
Key legal reasoning:
- Constitutional violation: The court held that the provision violated the right to equality (Article 14) and freedom of speech (Article 19(1)(a)).
- Proportionality test: The court applied a four-part proportionality test (legitimacy, suitability, necessity and balancing). The rules failed the test because the terms "fake, false, misleading" were vague and could cover legitimate criticism.
- Chilling effect: The provision created a chilling effect on free speech because any criticism of the government could potentially be labelled "fake" by the government's own unit.
- Article 19(2): Freedom of speech can be restricted only on the grounds listed in Article 19(2): sovereignty, security, public order, decency, morality, contempt of court, defamation and incitement to an offence. "Fake news about the government" is not a ground.
- Rule 3(1)(b)(v) of IT Rules 2021: Amended in 2023 to add the FCU provision. The court ruled the specific sub-clause unconstitutional while leaving the rest of the Rules intact.
Static linkage: Fundamental rights (Article 19), IT Act governance, censorship jurisprudence.
4. International Big Cat Alliance (IBCA): India's initiative
GS area: Environment (biodiversity), International Relations
The International Big Cat Alliance (IBCA), launched on 9 April 2023 (on the 50th anniversary of Project Tiger), continued to gain members.
Key facts:
- Founder: India, under PM Modi's initiative.
- Headquarters: India.
- Founding members: India, Nicaragua, Eswatini and Somalia.
- Total scope: 24 countries and 9 organisations.
- Funding: India committed $100 million over five years (approximately Rs 800 crore).
- Big cats covered: Tiger, Lion, Leopard, Snow Leopard, Cheetah, Puma and Jaguar.
- Project Tiger anniversary: Project Tiger launched in 1973. India now has the world's largest tiger population (approximately 3,682 as per 2022 census).
- India-IBCA connection: India's success in tiger conservation and cheetah reintroduction positions it as a global conservation leader.
Static linkage: Wildlife conservation, international environmental diplomacy.
5. ICAR-NISA Centenary: secondary agriculture
GS area: Economy (agriculture), Governance
The ICAR-National Institute of Secondary Agriculture (ICAR-NISA) celebrated its centenary year.
Key facts:
- Established: 1924 as the Indian Institute of Natural Resins and Gums.
- Renamed: 2022 to ICAR-National Institute of Secondary Agriculture.
- Location: Ranchi, Jharkhand.
- Ministry: Ministry of Agriculture and Farmers' Welfare.
- Secondary agriculture: Value-added processing of primary agricultural products. Examples include making jaggery from sugarcane, extracting rice bran oil from rice milling by-products, making flour from maize.
- Benefits: Increases farmer income beyond the primary crop sale. Reduces crop waste. Creates rural industries and employment. Improves sustainability by using crop residues.
- Policy relevance: PM Formalisation of Micro Food Processing Enterprises (PM FME) scheme supports secondary agriculture through capital and technical assistance.
Static linkage: Agricultural value chains, rural industrialisation, ICAR.
6. Kavach Centres: child drowning in Sundarbans
GS area: Governance (child welfare), Environment
Community-led "Kavach" centres were launched in the Sundarbans region in 2023 to prevent child drowning.
Key facts:
- Scale of problem: Three children drown daily in the Sundarbans (based on a 2019 survey).
- Why Sundarbans: The Sundarbans is a delta region with numerous water channels. Children of fishing families are constantly near water. There is limited adult supervision.
- Kavach centres: Community-run supervision centres for toddlers. They provide adult supervision while parents work. Swimming lessons and CPR training are included.
- UPSC GS Paper 4 angle: The initiative demonstrates community leadership, ethical responsibility and the power of local knowledge in solving local problems.
- Sundarbans geography: World's largest mangrove delta, shared between India (West Bengal) and Bangladesh. UNESCO World Heritage Site. Tiger reserve and biosphere reserve.
Static linkage: Disaster management (drowning as a public health issue), community governance, Sundarbans.
7. Briefly noted
- ICAR-NISA context: Secondary agriculture's contribution to India's agricultural economy is sometimes compared to the "Blue Revolution" for fisheries. The sector reduces over 20 per cent of food loss and waste.
- Sri Lanka AKD geography: Sri Lanka is separated from India by the Palk Strait. Its northern tip is 30 km from India's Rameshwaram. The Palk Bay and Palk Strait are key navigation routes.
Practice MCQs